From @jeffhorwitz

assume the following three files​:

Bar.pm​:
  say "in Bar.pm";

foo1.p6​:
  module Foo;
  use Bar;
  say "in Foo";

foo2.p6​:
  use Bar;
  module Foo;
  say "in Foo";

the output of foo1.p6 and foo2.p6 is the same when run using the p6
source​:

[jeff@​groovy perl6]$ ../../parrot perl6.pbc foo1.p6
in Bar.pm
in Foo
[jeff@​groovy perl6]$ ../../parrot perl6.pbc foo2.p6
in Bar.pm
in Foo

however, compile the scripts to PIR and the following happens​:

[jeff@​groovy perl6]$ ../../parrot foo1.pir
in Foo
in Bar.pm
[jeff@​groovy perl6]$ ../../parrot foo2.pir
in Bar.pm
in Foo

foo1.pir behaves differently from its p6 source -- it processes the "use"
*after* executing the body of the script, which is incorrect. the
placement of the module declaration is the only difference.

-jeff

From @pmichaud

On Mon Dec 29 12​:49​:10 2008, jhorwitz wrote​:

assume the following three files​:

Bar.pm​:
say "in Bar.pm";

foo1.p6​:
module Foo;
use Bar;
say "in Foo";

foo2.p6​:
use Bar;
module Foo;
say "in Foo";

This second version (foo2.p6) isn't valid Perl 6. Rakudo doesn't
recognize it as an error yet, but it is one.

That still leaves the question of why foo1.p6 is changing for the
compiled versus non-compiled version -- I'll look into it.

Pm

The RT System itself - Status changed from 'new' to 'open'

From sohtil@gmail.com

With current rakudo, the compiled version behaves the same as the
uncompiled one. The code in foo2.p6 is still accepted, though​:

$ ./perl6 foo1.p6
in Bar.pm
in Foo
$ ./perl6 foo2.p6
in Bar.pm
in Foo

$ ./perl6 --target=pir -o foo1.pir foo1.p6
in Bar.pm
$ ./perl6 --target=pir -o foo2.pir foo2.p6
in Bar.pm

$ ~/local/parrot/bin/parrot foo1.pir
in Bar.pm
in Foo
$ ~/local/parrot/bin/parrot foo2.pir
in Bar.pm
in Foo

This is Rakudo Perl 6, version 2010.08-119-gccde8dc built on parrot
2.7.0 r49158

Lithos

From @pmichaud

Currently Rakudo isn't supporting execution of pir scripts directly; thus
rejecting this ticket. (We may support this option in the future; for
now it's unsupported.)

Pm

@pmichaud - Status changed from 'open' to 'rejected'